THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX Vs. MR. FUMIO GOTO

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Reserved on: 08.07.2013 Decided on: 31.07.2013 + ITA 379/2007 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX XVI ....Appellant versus SH. SASHI MUKUNDAN ..... Respondent + ITA 387/2008 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX XVI ...Appellant versus MR. SHORT DONALD ..... Respondent + ITA 212/2009 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX ......Appellant versus MR. FUMIO GOTO ..... Respondent + ITA 15/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XIV .....Appellant versus MR. DUNCAN ETHERINGTION ..... Respondent + ITA 351/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. YASHIMITSU ZAUTSU ..... Respondent + ITA 408/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. IKUJU YABUKI ..... Respondent + ITA 450/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant ITA 379/2007 & connected matters Page 1 versus SHRI TOSHIHORU SUNAHARA ..... Respondent + ITA 534/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SOJITZ CORPORATION AS AGENT ..... Respondent + ITA 635/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. YASHIMITSU ZAUTSU ..... Respondent + ITA 1354/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. JASWINDER SINGH .... Respondent + ITA 1556/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. MOHAMMAD RAUFF NABI BAX ..... Respondent + ITA 1561/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. MOHAMMAD RAUFF NABI BAX ..... Respondent + ITA 370/2011 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus GORAM WESTERBERG ..... Respondent + ITA 1557/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. JOHN TRIPLETT ..... Respondent ITA 379/2007 & connected matters Page 2 + REV. PET. 708/2011 IN ITA 1369/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. FUMIO GOTO ..... Respondent + ITA 761/2005 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. K.P.HOSTELLEY ..... Respondent + ITA 798/2005 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. YOSHIO KUBO ..... Respondent + ITA 800/2005 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. YOSHIO KUBO ..... Respondent + ITA 680/2007 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. MOHAN RAI ..... Respondent + ITA 681/2007 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. MOHAN RAI ..... Respondent + ITA 1215/2008 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI XIV ..... Appellant versus MR. GHORAYEB EMILE, C/O AIR FRANCE ..... Respondent + ITA 494/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant ITA 379/2007 & connected matters Page 3 versus SH. HIROYASU KITADA ..... Respondent + ITA 508/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. HIROYASU KITADA ..... Respondent + ITA 577/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. SCOTT R BAYMAN ..... Respondent + ITA 631/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. VENKAT RAO SHRIDHAR ..... Respondent + ITA 699/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus MR. JEROME SUDAN ..... Respondent + ITA 1912/2010 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. PANKAJ SHAH ..... Respondent + ITA 528/2011 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-XVI ..... Appellant versus SH. MARCH FRANCOIS JEAN SOULACROUP ..... Respondent .....Appearance Through: Mr. Rajiv Tyagi with Mr. Ajay Kumar, Mr. Gyanendra Sharma and Ms. Renu Narula, Advocates, for respondent in ITA 379/07. ITA 379/2007 & connected matters Page 4 Mr. Pawan Sharma with Ms. Madhavi Swaroop, Advocates, in ITA 15/2010. Mr. Piyush Kaushik, Advocate, in ITA 450/10 & ITA 534/10. Ms. Amita Kalkal Chaudhary, Proxy for Mr. Naresh Kaushik, Advocate, in ITA 1354/10. Mr. S. Ganesh, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Pawan Sharma, Ms. Madhavi Swaroop, Ms. Roohina Dua and Ms. Preeti Goel, Advocates, in ITA 577/10. Mr. Satyen Sethi with Mr. Arta Trana Panda, Advocates, in ITA 1912/10. Ms. Shreya Verma, Advocate, for Respondent in ITA 681/07 & ITA 1215/08. Mr. Salil Kapoor, Mr. Vikas Jain, Mr. Manomeet Dalal and Ms. Preity Goel, Advocates, for Respondents in ITA 212/09, ITA 1556/10, 1561/10, 1369/10, 370/11, 494/10, 508/10 and ITA 631/10. CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.V. EASWAR MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT % 1. For detailed judgment please see ITA 441/2003 titled YOSHIO KUBO vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX. S. RAVINDRA BHAT (JUDGE) R.V. EASWAR (JUDGE) JULY 31, 2013 ITA 379/2007 & connected matters Page 5